04 May 2020

ROSWELL KILBOURNE, WONDERLUST, RIVER RAT


ROSWELL KILBOURNE, WONDERLUST, RIVER RAT

By Teresa Martin Klaiber, 2020

Growing up in Ashland, Kentucky, my parents and I would follow the ribbon of the Ohio River to Portsmouth, where we were born.  Sometimes we followed the river on the Kentucky side from Boyd County through Greenup County, crossing the bridge at Portsmouth. For variety we crossed the Ashland Bridge and drove through Lawrence County to Scioto County.  Mother would reminiscence about her friend, Betty Bryant, that lived on a showboat and how she loved to swim in the Ohio River.  She would say she could easily be a “river rat.” 

Taking day trips with my paternal grandmother, often lead us back to Burlington in Lawrence County, Ohio where her mother, Clara “Callie” Kilbourne was born in 1870.  My great grandmother lived long enough to hold me and see me learn to sit up before her death in Portsmouth in April 1950.   Grandmother would often point out where the Kilbourne’s resided, in Burlington, in a two-story house, along the river bank.  She told me stories about how the river played such an intricate role in the Kilbourne family life.  When I asked if they were “river rats” she would smile and say, yes, she guessed they really were.

Four generations of Roswell Kilbourne’s fill my genealogical chart.  Roswell (s/o Roswell; Roswell; Roswell; James; Joseph; John; Thomas) was born in Castleton, Rutland County, Vermont about 1800.  The farmers were known for sheep and the first industries in the town included mills.  By the age of 18, according to family, Roswell was working as fuller.  But It appears he had dreams and wonder lust.  When interviewed for a Kilbourne history, Roswell’s brother, Alanson told Payne Kenyon Kilbourne that he had not heard from his brother for more than thirty years, that he had gone to Indiana and talked about going to South America.[i]

By the time Roswell was 19 years old he met Rhoda Snapp, from Hampshire County, Virginia.[ii] This researcher still struggles to find out how they met or where they married.  Roswell and Rhoda purchased land in Vincennes, Indiana where it was paid off by 24 April 1820.[iii] The land lays on the Wabash River in what is northern Vincennes.[iv]  Between 1820 and 1826 Roswell and Rhoda had four children: Joseph, Maria, Roswell and Almira.  About the time Almira was born, in 1826, is apparently the last time Roswell’s brother Alanson had contact from him in Indiana.

The terminus of the Wabash River is the Ohio River west of Evansville.  The Ohio flows into the Mississippi at Cairo, Illinois where it flows pass Memphis, Tennessee.  According to the history of Vigo County the first steamboat arrived in Terre Haute, Vigo County about 1824/25, named the Florence. [v] with Captain Donne.[vi] The 2nd was the Ploughboy.[vii]  The article on the Ploughboy states it had traveled over five thousand miles up and down the Wabash, Ohio, and Mississippi River.  By 1829 steamboats including the Victory, William Tell, CriterionWASP, Virginian, Highlander, Talisman, Monongahela, were all reported as stopping in Vincennes…”[viii] In 1832 the steamboat named Vincennes launched from the town.  The list of more and more steamboats stopping at Vincennes were reported in newspapers that year. 

By 1832/1833 Rhoda was pregnant with her fifth child Rollin.  Family lore states that Roswell Kilbourne was killed in a steamboat accident and buried in Memphis, Tennessee in 1833.  Steamboat boiler explosions and fires were common place.[ix]  1833 was also the year of raging Cholera among the river men in and around Memphis.[x]  Newspapers reported accidents but only in a few cases do articles include a full list of victims. Roswell Kilbourne never made it to South America.

During the Civil War Roswell’s son Rollin stated on his enlistment that he was born in Wayne County, Virginia. Wayne was not formed until 1842 thus his place of birth would have been Cabell, Virginia where the Guyandotte River meets the Ohio, just across from Lawrence County, Ohio.  Further research is needed to ascertain if Rhoda and the children left Vincennes before or after the death of Roswell Kilbourne in 1833 near Memphis.

Rhoda remarried John Cunningham, 29 May 1845 in Lawrence County, Ohio.  He had four children by a previous marriage, all born in (W.) Virginia.  In 1847 the Cunningham’s had one more son Henry born in Lawrence County.  Both families were residing in Fayette township in various households in 1850.
Roswell Kilbourne, son of Roswell 1800-1833 was residing with his sister Almira Kilbourne Carter.  Almira had married John H. Carter the same year her mother remarried.  Almira and John were married 16 December 1845 in Lawrence County.  John Carter, while listed as a farmer in 1850 listed his occupation as “pilot of boat” in 1860.  Almira’s half-brother Henry Cunningham, now 13, was living with them in Fayette Township, Lawrence, Ohio. The township is bordered by the Ohio River.

 John and Almira Carter sold ½ acre of land adjacent the town of Burlington “whereas the county road leaves Washington Street…to the bank of the Ohio River”[xi] to Roswell Kilbourne. The Carter’s along with Henry Cunningham migrated to Linn County, Missouri. Roswell Kilbourne, born 18 March 1822, beside the Wabash River in Vincennes, Indiana, was now the owner of property on the Ohio River.  This certainly qualifies him for the urban term “river rat.”[xii]

Roswell Kilbourne was a carpenter, building and repairing boats along the river, as needed.  He married 10 October 1854 Sarah Jane Adams in Lawrence County, Ohio.[xiii]  Their first-born son, Ira born October 1855 died 7 December 1857.  He was buried in Greenlawn Cemetery, at Burlington, on Burlington-Macedonia Road that runs parallel to the Ohio River.  Five of their eleven children were born prior to the Civil War.  Besides, Ira, Almira, Sarah, Emma and Ida May were all born in Burlington township.  Sarah died 14 May 1864 and was also buried in Greenlawn Cemetery.

My great grandmother Clara told the family that during the Civil War he was held in New Orleans on suspicion of being a northern spy.[xiv]  This compiler is the owner of a letter written the 24th day of (month unreadable) 1865 from Roswell Kilbourne to wife Sarah Jane.  I have transcribed it complete with mis-spellings.

"Dear Wife, I recive your letter of eight and was glad to here from you but was sorry you was so --- about your money. it did not have time you will get before you get this. It found me well Capt. Warner is hear and has chartered out the boat again an will leave hear for home to morn i will send you more money by him i could not make out all of your letter tell the children i wold like to be with them on Chrismy and see wat the(y) get you must get them something for me and tell me wat the(y) get thenn as maney apples the can eat you never said whether you got more coal or corn. if you have not you will pay for it we will sill sum up red river. Warner is not on the Bostone he said nothing doing up thar so is will fight it out as long as i can and then com home to stay i want you to take good care of yourself an children. So I will close but remain your loving husband. R. Kilbourn. To S. Kilbourn.  I will send you seventy dollars by Cap Warner doe not kep nor move money by you than you want still get all you can of --- but doe not be to hard on him so he will not get mad or he will not pay you.”
While Kilbourne may have been detained at some point, the letter indicates that he is not in prison but earning money along the rivers.

Captain Warner, listed in Roswell Kilbourne’s letter to his wife, was Charles P. Warner who helped build and was the first  Captain of the Mollie Able.  The Mollie Able was built in 1864 with five boilers. She was launched at Jeffersonville, Indiana.  She was in Cincinnati in January 1864 getting her final touches along with Captain Warner. [xv] The usual run was from New Orleans to St. Louis.  The Mollie Able was severely damaged in the Great St. Louis Tornado in 1871 when the boilers exploded,[xvi] [xvii] rebuilt and late in her career ran the Red River. 

The Mollie Able is mentioned in The Rebellion Records: A Diary of American Events Volume 8, edited by Frank Moore, page 79….”April…1864…Just then a steamer…we supposed at first that she was the Mollie Able which the captain of our boat said was due at Fort Pillow …she was one of the boats the rebels had captured, …When we saw her coming we noticed that she was loaded with troops,; whether Union or Rebel we could not tell…The general said to our captain: “Can you run that boat down? He said: If it is the Mollie Able I can run right over her…got nearer, however we found she had Union troops on board…” 

The Memphis Bulletin, 6 January 1865 reported that Captain Warner and the “swift Mollie Able” were leaving for Vicksburg and New Orleans.  This places Warner in or near New Orleans and the subject of the Kilbourne letter.

Edna Ferber mentions a Mollie Able along with a showboat she names the Cotton Blossom in her novel Showboat (page 97).  The Herman T. Pott National Inland Waterways Library contains a picture of the Mollie Able  pushing the Cotton Palace. The actual picture was taken in 1929 for the movie version shot on the Sacramento River. According to one article Ferber’s named boat Cotton Blossom was changed to Cotton Palace because the actual owner of the showboat demanded extravagant fees for the name use in the movie.[xviii]

The Bostone mentioned in Kilbourne’s letter may be the second Bostona. The first one of that name ran from Cincinnati to Portsmouth, was dismantled in 1860 and the machinery used in building the 2nd Bostona. A third Bostona was built in Cincinnati in 1879 according to Marshall University’s digital library. The 2nd Bostona was on her maiden voyage and was the first on the scene in Memphis when the Sultana exploded 27 April 1865.
Riverboat historian James A. Wallen, a descendent of Captain Julian F. Davey of Ironton, Ohio of the second Bonanza, said that he was aware of at least four steamboats that were launched at Burlington, Ohio: Daniel Webster later known as Oliver H. Perry 1829; Irene 1844; The Billow 1846; and the Red Chief 1857.[xix] 

Of these, The Red Chief was owned by James Schute and Jesse Dillon of Lawrence County, Ohio and was said to be registered with the Confederate government[xx]  It was often in Alabama and New Orleans during the Civil War. By January 1865 she is listed as belonging to the US Quartermaster Department.[xxi] The Irene was a passenger packet that appears to have operated out of Opelousas, Louisiana during the Civil War.

Roswell Kilbourne was old enough to have possibly been a carpenter on any of the last three when they were built in Lawrence County, Ohio. It is believed that he was home on 12 May 1866 when his three year old daughter, Ida May” died and was buried along with her siblings in Greenlawn Cemetery at Burlington, Ohio.  Rhoda was pregnant, at the time, and gave birth to Mattie B. Kilbourn, their 6th child,  on the 24th at Burlington. 

Roswell continued his carpentry trade at their home in Burlington in the 1870’s and 1880’s.  My great grandmother, Clara “Callie” Kilbourne (Geer) was born in the house 19 January 1870.  Almira married William Loyal Hardy 17 May 1874 and their first child Fred Hardy Sr. was born in the house 23 June 1875.

It certainly was a full house.  Rhoda and Roswell had three sons between 1872 and March 1875: Frank, Fred and Edgar.  Edgar died of “brain fever” when he was one and was buried in Greenlawn.[xxii]


Photograph donated by Fred Hardy Jr. descendent of Almira “Myra” Kilbourne Hardy. If you look closely you can see the river to the left in background.

The Kilbourne’s moved to Ashland, Boyd County, Kentucky between 1886 and 1887.  But they never left the river.  Their home was as close to the river as possible; 810 West Front Avenue.  At the age of 72, the city directory still states that Roswell Kilbourne is a carpenter.  Sarah Jane died the 3rd of July 1898 of Brights Disease[xxiii]  On the 6th of July she was laid to rest in the cemetery at Burlington. 

Clara graduated from Ashland High School in 1889.  She went on to Barboursville Normal School which was later absorbed by Marshall College now University.  She cared for her father while teaching in the Ashland school system.  Roswell Kilbourn died 30 March 1902.  He was buried in his daughter Almira’s family plot near the Weeping Lady in Ashland Cemetery.  The Hardy’s and Clara had Sarah Jane re-interred beside him in the same family plot.

Three months after her father’s death, Clara “Callie” married George Page Geer in the Presbyterian Church at Ashland.  When her husband died in 1913 in Clarksburg, West Virginia he was brought back to Ashland to be buried next to her parents.  My great grandmother continued teaching after the death of her husband, moving to Portsmouth, Ohio. When she died in 1950 she was brought to Ashland and buried beside her husband in the same plot as her parents and sister. 

My grandmother, Clara Page Geer Martin, also a teacher in the Portsmouth, Ohio system, died 10 June 1998, and at her request was buried with her parents and grandparents.  At the age of 70 I often visit my grandmother, great grandparents and great great grandparents place of rest.  My father died a year after his mother and while not in the same plot, is also in Ashland Cemetery, as is my mother who loved the river.  May they rest in peace.  May the history of the river and my families love of the river along with the stories continue to be handed down generation after generation. 

Ol' man river
That ol' man river
He don't say nothing
But he must know something
Cause he just keeps rolling
He keeps rolling along
Rollin' along
He don't plant tators
He don't plant cotton
Them that plants 'em is soon forgotten
But ol' man river
He keeps rolling along
You and me
We sweat and strain
Body all aching
And wracked with pain
Tote that barge
Lift that bale
Get a little drunk
And you land in jail
I gets weary
Sick of trying
I'm tired of living
Feared of dying
But ol' man river
He's rolling along
Source: LyricFind
Songwriters: Jerome Kern / Oscar Ii Hammerstein















[i] Kilbourne, Payne Kenyon, The History and Antiquities of the Name and Family of Kilbourn. 1856. P. 188; 280
[ii] Daughter of Joseph Snapp and Margaret Craven
[iii] Bureau of Land Management, BLM Serial #: IN NO S/N, www.glorecords.blm.gov/PatentSearch (: , ), Accession/Serial: IN0030_.500 Roswell Kilbourn.
[iv] Terre Haute Tribune 2 Apr 1955. Legal Notice Vigo Superior Ct. to clear title of property known as lot #550 block 35 in Highland Place same being subdivision of S 10 T 12 N Range 9 w on recorded plat.  Both Roswell and Rhoda cited as deft. With address unknown.
[vi] Snow, John Fletcher. History of Adams County, Indiana. Page 31
[vii] Gilmore, Parker sketch of steamboat 1872 page 20 Dorothy Clark’s Terre Haute: Wabash River City.
[viii] Lawrence Lore. Blog. Illinois Historical Society Blog. 23 Jan. 2013
[ix] NOTE:  History of Memphis Tn by Judge JP Young 1912 p 375...steam boat disasters at or near Memphis...The Helen McGregor a Louisville New Orleans packet Feb 24 1830 exploded boilers at landing killing 50 many citizens of Memphis injured; Ap 9 1832 The Brandywine burned just above the city 175 lives lost...May 15 1835 Majestic blew up at Memphis landing 56 killed or seriously injured...
[x] Bruesch, S.R., The Disasters and Epidemics of a River Town: Memphis, TN 1819-1879
[xi] Ohio, Lawrence db, 26-282
[xii] Urban Dictionary: A community of people that live along a river. Known as tight knit community that always sticks together and looks out for its children. Also, spend a lot of leisure time along the river, fishing, boating, ect. People that live along a river are proud to be called "river rats!"
[xiii] Daughter of Solomon and Rhoda Bagley Adams
[xiv] Martin, Clara Page. Kilbourne Family 1550-1980. Unpublished manuscript
[xv] Cincinnati Inquirer, 7 Jan 1864
[xvi] LSU Digital Library. Louisiana State University Digital Library.
[xix] Wallen, James, Huntington, WV. Correspondence,  to Clara P. Geer Martin. 26 Jul 1978
[xx] Way, Frdk, Way’s Packet Directory, 389.
[xxi] New Orleans Times-Picayune, 21 Jan. 1865
[xxii] Ohio, Lawrence, death register 1-2 entry 515
[xxiii] Kentucky, Boyd deaths 1806-1909; Courthouse attic, sheet 1898 line #2

23 April 2020

Halterman Family Captives, Massacre & Survival


Halterman Family Captives, Massacre & Survival
Compiled by Teresa  Martin Klaiber 2020



Rosemount Overlook, Scioto County, Ohio
When I was a toddler my paternal grandmother, began teaching me to count by singing Ten Little Indians.  It is one of those little ditties that get stuck in your head.  When I was older, we went on outings that included climbing Rosemount Hill in Scioto County, Ohio.  Perched on a rock we could see much of the valley.  Grandmother taught me about the Scioto Valley and the proud Shawnee villages.  She was always ahead of her time, quietly explaining that they were eventually displaced and their life was not anything like the 1950 western cowboy and Indian movies.  As I sat spellbound by her tales, little did I know just how much my ancestors were intertwined with more than one Native American skirmish.

One of these events involves my maternal mother’s family. Several 1880’s county histories from southern Ohio give varied accounts concerning the capture of three Halterman boys in 1758.  Because given names are often repeated from generation to generation, and some authors simply repeat and embellish without documentation,  it has taken Haltiman/Haldeman/Halterman[i] researchers time to reconstruct the facts. 

My 3rd great grandfather Daniel L. Halterman was born 33 years after a horrible attack in Hawksbill, Augusta County, Virginia.  Daniel was born in Hardy County, Virginia, married in Shenandoah County and migrated to the Scioto Valley before 1820.  I have wondered if Daniel’s father, Jacob Haldiman sat him down, while overlooking the Shenandoah Valley, and told him the story of his captivity. If so, the story, was lost, in our branch of the family by the time my great grandfather was born.

The Haldeman/Halterman/Haltiman/Holdiman’s fled persecution of their Mennonite faith, migrating from Switzerland to Lancaster in colonial Pennsylvania, to the beautiful Shenandoah Valley hoping for the promise of religious freedom, good land and good fortune.   Christian was born about 1677 in Eggiwil Parish, Bern Switzerland, baptized there 13 May 1677, the son of Michael and Magdalena Gerber Haldiman.[ii]   [iii]  He and wife Christina Kneissley Haldeman settled in Lancaster County, along with three known children: Barbara, Jacob and John.


Christina’s father Anthony’s (also from Eggiwil) estate papers were filed in Lancaster County, 1733 listing Christian as an heir.  The first of the Mennonite settlers, had already migrated from Lancaster County, Pennsylvania to Massanutten in the Shenandoah Valley, Augusta County, about 1728[iv].  The Mennonites would have travelled the Great Wagon Road as it passed through Lancaster and entered the Shenandoah Valley where they would continue into the valley on the Great Warriors Trail. 

Christian’s son Jacob Haldiman married to Maria Catarina Boin on Muddy Creek, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania by the Rev. John Casper Stoever 13 May 1740.[v]  

A significant document known as The Treaty of Lancaster established rights to settle along the Warrior’s Trail in 1744.  Migration increased. The Haldiman family decided to join fellow Mennonites that had removed to Augusta County, Virginia, after the death of their 3rd son George Daniel Haldiman (January 1748 - September 1748) in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.[vi] 

The Shenandoah valley might have reminded them a little bit of what they might have seen in Switzerland.   The family of Jacob and Maria Catarina Boin Haldiman migrated with three little girls, sons Jacob (born 1742), Gabriel (born about 1743) and Christopher. Within the Massanutten Patent granted Jacob Stoever was the settlement that became known as Hawksbill or Brock’s Gap. The family moved shortly after George Washington had surveyed much of the area for Lord Fairfax in 1748. 

Researcher’s incorrectly state that during the time frame an attack at the settlement, was in Rockingham County.  Rockingham County was not formed until 1778 from Augusta. The area of Hawksbill is now in Page County, Virginia near the town of Luray.  Hawksbill Mountain is the highest point in Shenandoah National Park. Part of the Blue Ridge Mountains, the area takes my breath away when we have been able to visit.  There are several Indian burying grounds and signs of villages in today’s Page County which can be seen on Hawksbill creek.[vii] The Natives considered the area of Massanutten a common hunting ground.  During the French & Indian War many settlers in Virginia lost their lives.  Hawksbill would be just one in a list of many horrendous attacks. 

Researchers incorrectly state that the attack on Hawksbill was in August 1758.  The actual attack took place in May 1758.[viii]  Letters written to appeal to the Dutch church to help the Mennonite Refugees give the correct month.

Daniel L. Halterman’s father, Jacob was sixteen years old when the Native Americans attacked his family at Hawksbill.  Brother Gabriel was about 15 years old and the youngest Christopher just eight.  Glorified accounts tell how Indians attacked the John Stone family then the Haltiman/Holtiman’s.  The three little girls, one just a baby, and their mother were among the estimated fifty killed that day in May 1758.  To date the names of Jacob’s sisters are still lost in history.

Father, Jacob Haldeman managed to escape. The mother, and  two daughters  were killed by tomahawk and the baby girl smashed against the wall.   Sadly this is a common story told of many attacks during that time. One account goes so far as to say that the Indian’s were amused by the young boys so took them as captives after killing the mother’ Articles I have read the Natives took, those able, to replenish their own work forces. Like Mary Draper Ingles in 1755, the boys would have been forced to walk many miles back to villages in the Ohio valley.  “During the 1750’s and 1760s nearly two thousand captives lived in the Ohio villages.”[ix]

In some of the narratives, Christian is said to have also migrated from Lancaster, Colonial Pennsylvania to Hawksbill with Jacob’s family.[x]  His daughter Barbara’s mother-in-law was murdered during the attack and it is said that Christian’s wife, Christianna Kneissley Haldeman was killed during the hostility.  That version of the story has the elder Jacob and father Christian returning to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania together. Did they know that two of the boys, Jacob and Christopher survived?   

Tales say the boys were taken to Chalahgawtha, a Shawnee village.  This village was moved several times.  As with other written narratives readers assume that was present day Chillicothe which was in the area of one of the Chalahgawtha settlements, and ironically where descendent, my great grandfather, Stephen Simpson Halderman was born almost 95 years later.

Gabriel is said to have died the winter of 1759/60.  Smallpox struck the Indians around 1759-60.  Food for thought, a sad possibility, that he and others got smallpox from “smallpox blankets” given by the British as “gifts” with the intention of killing as many Indians as possible. An early horrible tale of germ warfare. The winter would be just as harsh on the captives and that alone, with lack of food and supplies, could have caused a child’s death.  In 1807 Gabriel was remembered when Jacob and wife Caty named a child after him (Jacob, Jacob, Jacob, Christian).  Christopher’s daughter Eve Halterman Evans would also name a son Gabriel Evans, born in 1820, in Jackson County, Ohio in remembrance of the captive Gabriel Haldeman.

Oral history says that Jacob was treated well and “adopted” by his captors.  A descendent of Christopher[xi] says he was not treated well. There are no first hand accounts that this compiler has located, as of this writing.  Where the boys kept together or separated into other tribes?

In November, after the horrible massacre it was duly recorded in the Augusta records that Jacob Haldeman “has removed out of the colony…”[xii] Along with most of the Mennonites, Jacob and father Christian returned to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.  It is exceedingly sad to think of these two men returning to Pennsylvania with so many hopes and dreams dashed. 

Jacob’s sister Barbara had married Michael Joseph Kauffman.  The Kauffman’s had also fled the Virginia colony returning to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.  Kauffman, Jacob Bomer, Samuel Bohm (Boehm) and Daniel Stauffer (Stoever) wrote to Holland,  7 September 1758, after returning to Lancaster County, describing the Mennonite refugees plight.  The correspondence states that the wives and children of Jacob Holtiman (as spelled) and John Stone were among the 50 people killed.  They received a reply in December that they were providing the Mennonites with 50 pounds English Sterling to come to their aide.[xiii] The letter does not specify how the funds were to be distributed.  Many had nothing but the shirts on their backs when they fled from the Indians.

Repeated narratives and published histories have been unclear about when Jacob was returned to the settlers.  One account says 1762 others 1764.

It never ceases to amaze me when I discover early valuable documents.  The Minutes of Conferences, held at Lancaster, August 1762. With sachems and warriors of several tribes of northern and western Indians. Pennsylvania Treaties. is one of those detailed and transcribed items.

Present on 13 August 1762 was James Hamilton Lt. Governor, William Logan, Benjamin Chew, Joseph Fox (among others) and many Chiefs of different nations including Tomago or Beaver, Chief of the Ohio Delawares.  Other Nations represented included the Shawnee, Kickapoe and Tuscaroras.

The Governor rose and went to the Place where the English Prisoners sat, and received them one by one, from the Hands of King Beaver, and here follow their Names.
  • Thomas Moore, taken from Potowmack, Maryland.
  • Philip Studebecker, taken from Conegocheague, Ditto.
  • Ann Dougherty, taken from Pennsylvania.
  • Peter Condon, taken from Ditto.
  • Mary Stroudman, taken from Conegocheague, Ditto.
  • William Jackson, taken from Tulpehocken, Ditto.
  • Elizabeth M' Adam, taken from Little Cove, Ditto.
  • John Lloyd, taken from Ditto, Ditto.
  • Eleanor Lancestoctes, taken from Ditto.
  • Dorothy Shobrin, taken from Big Cove, Ditto.
  • Richard Rogers, taken from Virginia.
  • Esther Rogers, taken from Ditto.
  • Jacob Rogers, taken from South Branch, Ditto.
  • Archibald Woods, taken from Ditto.
  • Christopher Holtomen, taken from Ditto.
  • Rebecca Walter, taken from Ditto.
  • Hans Boyer, a Boy, taken from not known from whence.



It was not just the Shawnee that raided Virginia, many other tribes, including the Delaware and Cherokee had joined during the Indian Wars.[xiv]  All the narratives I had read prior to finding the conference seem to assume it was the Shawnee that had taken all three boys. Four long years in a totally different environment than the boys were used to living.  From many articles, that this compiler has read, adjustment back to civilization must have been difficult. Many captives learned different skills and a different way of life in captivity.  Jacob is not released with his brother and may explain why narratives give two different years: 1762 and 1764.

As a condition of peace with the Ohio Indians Henry Bouquet had demanded the release of prisoners held by the Delawares and Shawnees.  The Articles of Agreement was finalized in November 1764.  The Shawnees were not as prompt as the Delaware and some captives were not released until 1765.[xv] “Between Bouquet’s advance ot the Muskingum in the fall of 1764 and the summer of 1765 over five hundred captives had been returned to…Fort Pitt.”[xvi]  A review of known lists by this compiler have yet to reveal when my ancestor, Jacob was released.

What is known from documentation the boys father, Jacob,  and their grandfather Christian, having returned to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania were both deceased by March 1764.  Their uncle Michael Koffman/Kauffman was administrator of both estates and directed to distribute Christian’s remaining funds to the representative of the eldest son Jacob as well as son John. The Orphan Court records show that Michael then acted as administrator of Jacob as well.  Neither of Jacob’s sons, Jacob or Christopher are cited in the accounts.[xvii]

Both brothers reappear in Virginia in the 1780’s, active in Shenandoah and Hardy county. Jacob received a land grant in Hardy County, Virginia 6 Aug. 1789 on the headwaters of Lost River.[xviii]  He had property in both Hardy and Shenandoah County.  He left all his possessions to his wife Elizabeth when he died before November 1811 in Shenandoah County.[xix]

Christopher settled back in Hardy County with wife Eve and in 1803 gave a deposition concerning some disputed lands stating he had lived with his father Jacob Halterman in Brocks Gap between 1755-1760.[xx]

I am saddened by behavior of  humanity that has created chaos in our world.  The Mennonites faith emphasized peace not war yet in search of their own freedoms they and many others forced Native tribes to fight for what they believed in.  Sitting on a rock listening to stories with my grandmother, on Rosemount Hill, brought me peace as a child.  For many years we used Rosemount as a short cut as we travelled from central Ohio to Kentucky.  I never failed to think of the Shawnee and my grandmother’s stories when we drove over the hill. Knowing that a new by-pass was about to open, and we might not go that way again,  I had hubby pull over one last time.  It has been sixty-six plus years since I learned Ten Little Indians.  My journey has opened doors and my head is full of stories I learned along the way.  The trees, on Rosemont, have grown but the view is still there. The Scioto Valley, so rich in history, so peaceful to look at perched high on a rock.












[i] Varied spellings are utilized in legal documents throughout the history of the family.
[ii] Kirchenbucher der kirchgemeinde Eggiwil. Taufrodel Nr.1 1648-1697. Satate Archives of Canton Bern, Switzerland, page 184.
[iii] Kirchenbucher der kirchgemeinde Eggiwil. Eherodel Nr. 1.. State Archives of Canton Bern, Switzerland Michael and Magdalena married November 1667
[iv] Many online articles suggest the Haldiman’s migrated with the first Mennonites to Massanutten, they did not.
[v] Records of Rev. John Casper Stoever Bapt. And M. 1730-1779 p 57.
[vi] Pennsylvania, Lancaster Muddy Creek KB
[vii]Kercheval, Samuel.  History of the Valley of Virginia 1833
Vii Helen Horbeck Tanner, Atlas of great Lake Indian History. Norman, OK 1987. 66
[x] His daughter Barbara’s mother-in-law was murdered during the attack as well and in one instance it is said that Christian’s wife, Christianna Kneissley Haldeman was also killed during that hostility
[xi] Gabriel Evans acct
[xii] Virginia, Augusta, Order Bk 1 p 219
[xiii] Richard K MacMaster Danuel L. Horst, Rober F. Ulle, Conscience in Crisis: Mennonite and Other Peace Churches in America, 1739 (N.p.: n.p., n.d.), page 126-7.

[xiv] The Virginia Gazette, Williamsburg, VA 16 Jan 1761  “Nov 22 Affairs in the Cherokee Nation have taken such an unfavourable turn….Oct 29 …extract of a letter…some other Indians who had carried four prisoners with them…If this is true we must give over all thoughts of ever freeing our people again, who are prisoners in the Nation, their number according to the …accounts we can get is near 200….
[xvi] Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography. Vol 125 #3. Redeeming the Captives: Pennsylvania Captives among the Ohio Indians…
[xvii] Pennsylvania, Lancaster, , page 69: fhl 007726361, Orphan Ct. Misc. book 1763-1767; , .
[xviii] WV Land Grants 1-76 bk U p 1 writ 13 May 1788
[xix] Virginia, Shenandoah, Wb 1 p 476
[xx] Lyman Chalkely, Chronicles of the Scotch-Irish Setlement in Virginia: Extracted from the Original Court Records of Augusta County 1745-1800, 828 (Baltimore, MD: Genealogical Publishing Co., 1965), page 42.